Why communicators must spot reputational risk early and why PR should support safeguarding, never replace it.

The UK’s media and creative industries are once again being forced to confront an uncomfortable truth that a polished public response cannot compensate for a workplace culture that has allowed harmful behaviour to continue.
This week, culture secretary Lisa Nandy met senior figures from broadcasting, publishing, entertainment and sport to discuss how their organisations tackle bullying, abuse and whistleblowing. Those attending included representatives from the BBC, Sky, Channel 4, Netflix, HarperCollins, Bafta and the Football Association.
The questions reportedly put to industry leaders were practical ones. How is bullying challenged? Can whistleblowers raise concerns without losing their careers? Do safeguarding systems protect freelancers as effectively as permanent employees?
These are not communications questions in the traditional sense. They concern leadership, safeguarding, governance, employment and, where appropriate, the police. But they are also central to reputation, because the way an organisation behaves will eventually shape the way it is seen.
That is why senior communicators need to be involved before a problem becomes public. Their role is not to conceal wrongdoing, soften allegations or protect powerful people. It is to recognise when the gap between what an organisation says and what it does is becoming a serious reputational risk and to make sure leaders understand that the gap must be fixed, not merely explained.
When a crisis breaks, the communications team is often asked to prepare holding lines, respond to journalists, brief spokespeople and monitor reaction. By then, however, the most important decisions may already have been made.
Someone may have raised a concern and been ignored. A manager may have protected a high performer. A freelancer may have decided it was safer to leave quietly than make a complaint. Leaders may have known that a policy existed without checking whether anyone trusted the process behind it.
No combination of carefully chosen words can undo those decisions.
The eventual statement still matters. It should be accurate, accountable, sensitive and clear about what will happen next. But communications cannot carry the weight of an organisation’s response alone. If the underlying behaviour continues, even the best statement becomes another source of risk because it creates promises against which the organisation can be judged.
Businesses often think of reputation as something external: coverage, social-media conversation, online reviews or stakeholder opinion. In reality, reputation starts inside the organisation. It is built through the experience of employees, freelancers, customers, suppliers and partners, particularly when something goes wrong.
Good communicators spend their working lives considering how decisions will be understood by different audiences. They look for inconsistencies, unsupported claims and questions that leaders may not have considered. They know that what feels reasonable inside a boardroom can look very different to an employee, customer or journalist.
That perspective is valuable well before a crisis.
A senior communicator should be able to ask: if this decision became public tomorrow, could we justify it? Are we saying that people can speak up while rewarding managers who discourage complaints? Are we promoting inclusion while disabled employees or customers encounter obvious barriers? Are we describing an incident as isolated when we have not yet established whether similar concerns exist?
These questions are not about being negative or obstructive. They help an organisation identify where a reputational problem is actually an operational, ethical or cultural problem in disguise.
Communicators can also identify patterns across information that may sit separately elsewhere. One complaint may be held by HR, another may appear in customer feedback and a third may surface through social media or a journalist’s enquiry. Each incident can look minor in isolation. Together, they may reveal a wider issue that needs senior attention.
This is one reason communications leaders need access to decision-makers. If PR is treated only as the team that promotes good news or handles press enquiries, the organisation loses an important early-warning function.
It is easy to treat safeguarding and culture failures as problems for broadcasters, public bodies or global employers. Smaller businesses face many of the same risks, sometimes with fewer formal protections.
In a founder-led company, people may not know where to raise a concern if it involves the founder or a member of the leadership team. Policies may have been downloaded to meet a requirement but never discussed with staff. Freelancers and contractors may be central to the business while remaining outside its normal reporting processes. Close working relationships can make people more reluctant to challenge behaviour because the professional and personal boundaries feel blurred.
The answer is not to create layers of bureaucracy for the sake of appearances. It is to establish clear, credible routes for raising concerns; define who is responsible for responding; bring in independent expertise when needed; and make sure nobody’s commercial value places them beyond scrutiny.
For small businesses, this can also be an important point of resilience. A concern handled early, fairly and professionally is less likely to cause further harm than one dismissed until an employee leaves, a customer complains publicly or a journalist starts asking questions.
There is a dangerous version of crisis communications in which the objective is simply to make the story go away. It focuses on the shortest possible statement, the quickest possible news cycle and the minimum admission that can be made without creating additional liability.
That approach may reduce attention temporarily, but it does not resolve the problem. It can also make matters worse if people affected by the issue feel the organisation is minimising their experience or protecting itself at their expense.
PR should help an organisation communicate responsibly. It can advise on transparency, prepare leaders for difficult questions, correct misinformation and ensure people receive timely, accessible information. It can help the business explain what it knows, what it does not yet know and what action is being taken.
PR cannot investigate allegations, determine whether somebody is safe, replace specialist HR or legal advice, or decide whether a matter should be reported to a regulator or the police. It should never be asked to intimidate complainants, obscure evidence or create a positive campaign intended to distract from unresolved harm.
Where safeguarding is involved, the priority must be protecting people and following the correct process. Communications supports that response; it does not lead or replace it.
The Creative Industries Indepedent Standards Authority now provides an external route for workers in film, television, music and theatre to raise qualifying whistleblowing concerns. Its work is particularly relevant to sectors built around freelance employment, short contracts and informal networks, where people may reasonably fear that speaking up will damage their future opportunities.
The principle applies far beyond the creative industries. A reporting mechanism is only useful if people know it exists, understand how it works and believe they will not be punished for using it.
Senior communicators should not wait for an allegation to become public before asking how their organisation would respond. They should work with leadership, HR, legal, safeguarding specialists and operational teams to understand where reputational risks could emerge and whether the business’s actions support its public claims.
That might mean reviewing whether crisis plans reflect the reality of hybrid work and freelance teams. It could mean checking that internal reporting routes are understandable and accessible. It may involve challenging leaders who want to make broad claims before an investigation has established the facts.
Sometimes it means advising the organisation to say less publicly while doing more behind the scenes – provided silence is not being used to avoid accountability.
The communicator’s value lies partly in being willing to deliver an unwelcome message: this is not primarily a press problem. The organisation needs to change what it is doing.
The pressure now facing the media and entertainment industries should prompt every organisation in any sector to look beyond its crisis plan.
Does your team know how to raise a concern? Would the process still work if the complaint involved a senior or commercially important person? Are freelancers, contractors and temporary workers protected? Would leaders hear about a pattern of concerns before a journalist did? And does the organisation behave in a way that supports the values it promotes publicly?
If the answer to any of those questions is unclear, the solution is not a better statement.
PR can help identify risk, challenge complacency and communicate action honestly. But credibility ultimately depends on what an organisation does when nobody is watching and whether it acts properly when someone finally speaks up.
You cannot communicate your way out of a culture problem. You have to address the culture.
Hendrix Rose PR provides senior-led communications support for ambitious start-ups and SMEs, helping leaders identify reputational risks, respond responsibly and build credible visibility before issues reach crisis point. Get in touch if you'd like to find out more.